Comparison
Two mature, free, proven relational databases. What you already run, the shape of your data and the operational habits your team will build decide it.
For a new application with a free choice, PostgreSQL is the better default because of its range. Richer types model the domain directly. JSONB gives indexed document storage in the same transaction as relational data. Several index types answer awkward queries, transactional DDL rolls back failed migrations cleanly, and extensions keep geospatial, vector and time-series work in one database.
MySQL is the right answer when you already run a MySQL estate, your team knows its operational behaviour well, your workload is read-heavy web traffic scaled across replicas, or your software assumes it. WordPress, Magento and much PHP software are tested against MySQL every day. A database your team can diagnose at three in the morning beats a more capable one they cannot.
PostgreSQL asks for operational habits in return. Autovacuum must keep up with dead row versions, or bloat and slow queries follow. Each connection is a full process, so a busy application needs a pooler. Major-version upgrades need planning, and automatic failover is assembled with tooling or bought from a managed service.
The gap between them has narrowed. Modern MySQL on InnoDB has ACID transactions, row-level locking, foreign keys, check constraints, a JSON type, window functions and common table expressions, and it rejects invalid data by default. PostgreSQL still has the richer type system, more index types, transactional schema changes and an extension mechanism that absorbs whole categories of infrastructure.
The projects still differ in shape. PostgreSQL is an extensible, standards-oriented data platform: PostGIS makes it a serious geospatial database, pgvector adds similarity search, and built-in full-text search covers a lot of in-app search. MySQL is a fast, dependable relational store for web-shaped workloads, with heavily exercised replication and an ecosystem where almost every operational problem is already documented.
Open what matters to you.
PostgreSQL’s types solve real modelling problems. A booking system becomes a range type with an exclusion constraint that makes double-booking impossible at the database level. Tags become an array with a GIN index. A valid email address becomes a domain defined once. MySQL’s smaller type set covers most schemas and produces portable tables, but multi-valued and interval data must be modelled around the gap, often with rules in application code.
JSONB lets the structured core of a domain stay in typed columns while variable parts, such as per-tenant fields and integration payloads, sit beside them in one transaction. That removes a common reason to run a separate document store. MySQL’s JSON type handles a handful of semi-structured fields well, with generated columns or functional key parts for indexing, and grows awkward once documents carry real weight.
Extensions let PostgreSQL absorb systems that would otherwise need their own deployment, backups and security. PostGIS adds geometry and geography types, spatial indexes and a large function library for catchment zones, geofencing and nearest-branch queries. pgvector adds similarity search beside the rows it describes. TimescaleDB handles time series and pg_trgm handles fuzzy matching. MySQL has spatial types for simple proximity work, but real GIS problems favour PostGIS.
Extensions have costs. Your managed host must support them, they must stay compatible when you upgrade, and a lagging extension can block a major-version upgrade. MySQL 9 added a vector data type, while indexed similarity search is mainly offered through Oracle’s HeatWave service. Used deliberately, extensions can turn a proposed architecture of four data stores into one well-configured PostgreSQL database.
Both databases use MVCC, so readers and writers do not block each other. PostgreSQL writes a new row version on update and leaves the old one in the table for vacuum to reclaim. On write-heavy tables with default settings, dead tuples become bloat: more pages to scan, less useful cache, slower queries. Vacuum also prevents transaction-ID wraparound, and long-running transactions stop it cleaning up.
InnoDB keeps old versions in the undo log and purges them quietly, which suits teams without database specialists. PostgreSQL also runs one process per connection, so hundreds of direct connections exhaust the server before the hardware; put PgBouncer in front and size backends to your cores. Tuned autovacuum, a pooler and monitoring for bloat and long transactions make PostgreSQL very reliable.
MySQL’s binary log replication with GTIDs is among the most exercised mechanisms in the industry, and Group Replication with InnoDB Cluster gives a supported self-healing cluster. PostgreSQL replicates through the write-ahead log: streaming replicas are byte-identical, and logical replication enables cross-version upgrades with a short cutover. Automatic failover needs Patroni, repmgr, pg_auto_failover or a managed service, and improvising it risks split-brain.
The isolation defaults differ. PostgreSQL uses read committed, where each statement sees a fresh snapshot; InnoDB uses repeatable read, where a transaction reads from one snapshot and locking reads behave differently. Code that assumes one can misbehave under load on the other. PostgreSQL also offers true serialisable isolation, which detects conflicts and aborts one transaction, a strong alternative to hand-written application locking.
From MySQL to PostgreSQL, tables translate almost mechanically; the work is around them. Reset sequences after loading, widen unsigned integers with a check constraint, clean zero dates, and turn ENUMs into enum types or lookup tables. Comparisons that were case-insensitive become case-sensitive unless you use citext. Rewrite backtick quoting and MySQL-specific functions, and find every report or script that runs raw SQL.
The reverse is harder when the schema used arrays, ranges, domains, exclusion constraints or extensions such as PostGIS, which must be remodelled or replaced. Either way, load a full copy, test the application against it, keep the target current with logical replication or change data capture, and verify with checksums before a short cutover. Move for a missing capability, rarely for general dissatisfaction.
Not in a way that generalises. Performance in both depends on the right indexes, set-based SQL and configuration tuned for your data. MySQL is very quick at primary key lookups on a table clustered by that key, the read-heavy web pattern it grew up serving. PostgreSQL tends to do better on complex joins, analytics and queries that use its specialised index types.
No. That reputation came from old permissive defaults that truncated values and accepted invalid dates. Modern MySQL runs in strict mode by default, enforces check constraints and rejects bad data. The residual risk is inherited: older estates may carry permissive settings and data that will not survive strict mode. PostgreSQL has a richer constraint vocabulary for expressing invariants in the schema.
JSONB is PostgreSQL’s binary JSON type: fast to query, with containment and path operators and GIN indexes that reach inside documents. MySQL has a native JSON type with a solid function library, indexable through generated columns or functional key parts. It suits a handful of semi-structured fields and becomes thinner once documents carry real weight in the model.
No. Those platforms and their plugins, themes and integrations are built and tested against MySQL, so moving means fighting your own stack. Keep MySQL, use strict mode, size the InnoDB buffer pool to hold the working set, index around real queries and add read replicas when traffic justifies it. Run any PostGIS or pgvector need as a separate service.
Less often than architecture diagrams suggest. On PostgreSQL, JSONB covers most document needs, built-in full-text search covers catalogue and in-app search, and pgvector covers most retrieval workloads, all with one backup and one security model. Add a specialised store when the evidence demands it. On MySQL, those needs push you towards separate systems sooner.
Start a project
Tell us what you’re building and what it has to work with. We’ll tell you which option fits and why.
Or email [email protected]