Comparison
VICIdial runs on Asterisk. The choice is whether to adopt a ready-made contact centre application or build your own on the engine.
If your requirement is campaign shaped, choose VICIdial. Lists of numbers, agents working through them, dispositions, predictive pacing and an abandonment limit are all already built and proven in production. Rebuilding them on raw Asterisk means writing and maintaining an application whose hardest parts, pacing, agent state, list recycling and call-time rules, look simple in a design document and are not.
If your requirement is not campaign shaped, build on Asterisk. IVR-heavy self-service, routing by skill or account into a back office, and voice embedded in your own product each need an engine you drive, and FreeSWITCH deserves a look alongside it. Bending a campaign dialler into that shape means spending the project fighting assumptions VICIdial makes for you.
If you already run an Asterisk PBX and now need campaign dialling, stand VICIdial up as its own system beside the PBX and connect the two over SIP. Predictive dialling is an application with its own database, state and load profile. Grown inside a PBX dialplan, it turns the PBX into something nobody can safely change.
VICIdial runs on Asterisk. Asterisk is the telephony engine beneath every VICIdial deployment: it terminates the SIP trunks, executes the dialplan and originates and bridges the calls. Installing VICIdial installs Asterisk. So this comparison stands in for two other questions: build a contact centre on raw Asterisk or adopt VICIdial, and, if you already run an Asterisk PBX, whether you need VICIdial as well.
Asterisk gives you a highly capable, fully programmable telephony platform and almost none of the features a call centre manager asks for by name. VICIdial gives you those features already built, in exchange for accepting its model of how a call centre works. Which trade is right depends on whether your call flows look like outbound campaigns against lists of leads, or like something else.
Open what matters to you.
Asterisk deals in channels, media, protocols and a dialplan that decides what happens when a call arrives or is placed. It knows nothing about leads, campaigns, agents or dispositions, by design, and a large share of the world’s voice infrastructure is built on it. VICIdial wraps that engine in a web tier for agent and admin screens, a MySQL database for leads and live agent state, and a dialler process that decides how many calls to place.
That layering has a practical consequence. When an agent presses a button, the chain of events ends in Asterisk originating or bridging a call. The worst VICIdial faults, such as dropped calls, one-way audio and calls that connect and then die, are usually diagnosed at the Asterisk, network and carrier layers. Running VICIdial well takes Asterisk skills plus application skills, and the same people often cover both.
Write down what you would have to build. A schema for leads and campaigns. Dial ordering, filtering and recycling. Reliable call-time, timezone and do-not-call enforcement, because failure there is a regulatory matter. Pacing: deciding how many calls to place from free agents, call durations, answer rates and the abandonment limit, a feedback control problem that is easy to underestimate. Then an agent screen, recording tied to leads, real-time floor views, historical reports and an admin interface.
That is a product, and once it exists you maintain it: every bug, every regulatory change, every new report request. VICIdial hands you all of it, proven under load, in exchange for its model and its interface. For a campaign operation that is a good trade. When half your requirement sits outside the model, a smaller system on Asterisk that does exactly your job is easier to build and to operate.
Name the new requirement precisely. More extensions, better internal routing, hunt groups, voicemail, conferencing or a smarter inbound IVR are PBX work, and your existing Asterisk system is the place to do it. Adding a contact centre suite to solve a PBX problem gives you two systems to operate and no capability you could not have had by extending the one you run.
Outbound campaign dialling with agents, lists, pacing and dispositions does need what VICIdial provides. Run it as its own system with its own servers, database and carrier capacity, sized for real campaign concurrency. Connect it to the PBX at the SIP layer where the two must meet: transfers to internal extensions, queue overflow, a shared trunk provider. A busy campaign then cannot take down internal telephony.
Neither option has a licence fee, and both carry the same operating duties. Servers must be sized against real concurrency, patched and monitored. Carrier channels set a hard ceiling on calls in flight. Audio quality depends on network latency and jitter. Telemarketing rules, recording consent and retention follow the operation, whichever software runs it. VICIdial gives you places to enforce some of them. On raw Asterisk you build those controls yourself.
Security applies equally to a bare Asterisk PBX and a VICIdial cluster. Asterisk-based systems are scanned constantly for toll fraud, and an exposed box can route expensive international traffic overnight with the carrier still expecting payment. Locked-down SIP and management surfaces, strong credentials, rate limiting, brute-force protection, carrier-side dialling restrictions, spend alerts and monitoring for abnormal call patterns belong on both paths.
Moving from raw Asterisk to VICIdial is mostly a build. Your dialplan does not become campaigns. Leads held in a custom application can be mapped to VICIdial’s schema and loaded as lists, which is usually the largest single task. Carrier relationships, trunk configuration, codec choices and network tuning all carry over. Stand VICIdial up on its own servers, prove call quality under real dial pressure, then move campaigns across.
Moving from VICIdial to a custom Asterisk system is a software project. Leads, dispositions, recordings and history sit in a MySQL schema you can read, so the data is accessible. What must be rebuilt is everything the application did quietly: pacing, agent state, list handling, call-time enforcement, recording association and reporting. Often the better route is to carve out the one workflow that does not fit and leave VICIdial running the campaigns.
No. VICIdial is built on Asterisk and uses it as its telephony engine, so installing VICIdial installs and configures Asterisk underneath. They sit at different layers. The real choice is between adopting VICIdial as a ready-made contact centre application and building your own application on Asterisk directly.
Not through the dialplan alone. A PBX can originate calls, but predictive pacing means continuously deciding how many calls to place from free agents, answer rates, call durations and your abandonment limit, and holding that state reliably. That is an application. Run a dialler as its own system beside the PBX and connect the two at the SIP layer.
Yes. VICIdial’s web screens make it look like an ordinary application, but the most serious faults, such as dropped calls, one-way audio and calls that connect then fail, sit in the Asterisk, network or carrier layers. Diagnosing them means reading Asterisk logs, understanding SIP and knowing the trunk configuration. Without that skill, every hard problem becomes an outage of unknown length.
FreeSWITCH is an alternative to Asterisk: another open-source telephony engine. It is a strong candidate for a custom voice application, especially where media handling or fine-grained programmatic control matters. Like Asterisk, it gives you no dialler, agent screens or campaign management. If you are building the application yourself, evaluate both engines against your own call flows.
List the things your call handling must do that a generic contact centre would not. If the list is short and peripheral, adopt VICIdial and configure around it. If it is long, or central to how the business makes money, build on the engine. A quicker test: if your people work through a list of numbers and someone tracks the abandonment rate, you want a dialler.
Start a project
Tell us what you’re building and what it has to work with. We’ll tell you which option fits and why.
Or email [email protected]